Originally Posted by Netav
Well yes, of course this Halsin interaction ruins her for no reason at all while having no impact on the game/story at all(which is way we call it OOC).

Your picture with early banter in act1(when you don't have any relationship) is actually foreshadowing of what she becomes in act3
lovesick puppy that is waiting for Tav, try pressing different options in her ending dialogue(before the epilogue)
and there she has no idea of who she is or what she wants. It actually fits well with DJ SH story later on too, Selunite breaks all of this though(you could even argue that if you are romancing her - she throws the spear away for the sake of love, because she knows that she isn't allowed to have it as Sharran). "Last night was perfect" pic is out of context too.

I'd say her story/romance is very beautiful and consistent if you ignore Halsin's intreactions(for now)
she isn't manipulating Tav or anything like this, she doesn't acknowledge Halsin's presence at all even if you go through all of these questionable scenarios(and accept his romance offer). She doesn't say a word to Halsin when unromanced, she doesn't try to include herself in orgy when she is unromanced and Halsin is romanced, she doesn't have any banter when unromanced both or only Halsin is romanced, she literally doesn't do anything...
. But knowledge is power and burden sometimes. Just send your feedback(preferably not in agressive manner) https://larian.com/support/baldur-s-gate-3#modal
For me, Shadowheart's party banter in Act 1 is indifferent. There are some where Wyll flirts with Lae'Zel about three times (even with Shadowheart), but they reject him (I don't remember what Shadowheart says but it was something quite similar to not wanting to be a spare lover when she rejects Wyll). There is even a scenario in the game where it is implied that Lae'Zel had sex with Wyll or Astarion. The writer could have made Halsin and Shadowheart have sex in Act 1 and it would have made no difference to me. It's the interactions between Shadowheart and Halsin in Act 3 that I don't like, which occur when Shadowheart is in a romance with Tav.

Last edited by Sobocles; 08/01/24 06:14 PM.