Originally Posted by Sobocles
For me, Shadowheart's party banter in Act 1 is indifferent. There are some where Wyll flirts with Lae'Zel about three times (even with Shadowheart), but they reject him (I don't remember what Shadowheart says but it was something quite similar to not wanting to be a spare lover when she rejects Wyll). There is even a scenario in the game where it is implied that Lae'Zel had sex with Wyll or Astarion. The writer could have made Halsin and Shadowheart have sex in Act 1 and it would have made no difference to me. It's the interactions between Shadowheart and Halsin in Act 3 that I don't like, which occur when Shadowheart is in a romance with Tav.

For Lae'zel sleeping with others I think it's when you romance her but you sleep with other people in the beginning so she's trying to make you jealous. Fair enough, I guess. If Shadowheart did that in the beginning I think I'd also have a problem because she made you wait all that time up until Act 3 to finally make love with her but if she did it with someone else so early in the game that would be pretty insulting. I don't know but I think that's probably around the same level as grossness as Halsin's bullshit in Act 3. Then again it wouldn't have made the topic we're discussing so shocking to discover.

Honestly this thing would be so simple to fix. Change the brothel dialogue with Halsin to be the same without him and remove the disapproval. Everybody wins. The orgy people have something, and Halsin existing wouldn't be spit on our faces and we don't have to get rid of him. A modder with some free time can probably do it (if there are any modders here pls help lol).