I feel this so hard. Just had this scene and it left me feeling empty. Like I only let her do her thing because I knew I was going to be there for her no matter what happens next.
It feels horrible to be just standing there and doing nothing. Honestly if I knew that I'd have chosen differently just because of this one scene that goes against everything I believed our romance was about.
It's legit the only cutscene in the game so far that should imo get a rework. There should be way more dialogue, option to hug her, option to stay with her, honestly it could even transform into a walk through the city where you just talk about everything, the future etc.
Let me tell you something that I didn’t expect but that may improve your experience of the game:
Act 3 spoilers
I 100% believe that saving her parents is the better choice even though it requires a persuasion roll. I had a really good experience in the final scenes and epilogue after saving them. In the end she seems genuinely happy and I will now never make a different choice.