At this point I am close to just uninstalling the game and leaving for good, as there is nothing for me here but misery with each damn patch. Bugs, issues, inconsistencies I can handle all day long, but butchering a character like this through awful writing? Never.
So to quote Minthara directly from this horseshit scene to express how I feel about it; "Killing me would've been a mercy! At least it would've spared me of hearing this drivel!".
Sad to watch it. For me the whole arc of Dark Urge is a big joke (especially reaction of companions after one bard incident). I don't understand this character and don't want to. Just played him to know and that's it. So this new line of Minthara for Dark Urge just proved my point of view for me and it didn't bother me at all (and it didn't ruin Minthara for me). I'm sure they will fix it (or I hope so but looking at this tendency they will actually fix it like she will really break up with redeemed durge after rejecting Bhaal).