I'll take it from the top:

I feel that in many cases "I already am in a relationship" is leading the other person on. It implies that if you were not already in a relationship, you would consider their advances. Hence my mentioning of a hierarchy, it is suggested that if the current relationship ends, they'd be in the game again. This might be what you wish to convey, but if you are simply not interested in them, because you have different priorities in life &c, it''s dishonest.

The two characters in game whom you can tell that you are already with someone else are Halsin and Minthara. Halsin replies by telling you that he'd be open for a poly-relationship, while Minthara suggests that you should simply break up with your current partner to be with her. Both can be avoided if you tell them that you are simply not interested in them as a romantic partner. I think it's Lae'zel who has the "I am flattered, but I am not interested." option which for me is the best way out because it acknowledges your appreciation while at the same time shutting down the subject without question.


I am also ok with some dialogue and information being reserved for certain situations. As Arne states, it adds to the replay value of the game. Some of this information is also not locked behind one dialogue, but available through different channels. When you listen to Shadowheart's banter with Astarion, I thought it noticeable that she is more careful with him than with the other guys. When he gives a catty or evasive answer to one of her questions, she usually follows up with a gentler question. I would just in general prefer to have more of these small conversations with your companions. I also really like the moments when you notice a landmark, and the group just starts talking amongst themselves.

Originally Posted by Marielle
Originally Posted by Anska
Other than that, I think it's nice that now Wyll and supposedly Halsin (I couldn't really check this yet) only proposition you in Act 2/3 when you have flirted with them during the party in act 1. No need to make poor Wyll sad because you have to reject his dance proposal any longer.

I would like to clarify - only when flirting at a party? And if not flirting, they won't propose?

I can't say for sure for Halsin. He had a new, platonic dialogue when finishing his quest in the Shadowcurse, but he spent a very long time with Orin in my recent run, so I am not completely sure if I have not simply missed the time-window for his proposition. Wyll though, doesn't seem to start his dance scene if you did not previously flirt with him during the Tiefling party (which is really the only occasion you can flirt with him) since patch 6.