To me all this moaning says one thing - Minthara never should been added as recruitable and romanceable to being with. Halsin same.
Agree, jobs done in a half ass way are better not done at all.
While I do agree with the sentiment, I find Minthara a good companion to have on an evil playthrough. Even if she is rough and a bit unfinished around the edges, she is not that unfinished that I found it unbearable to have her there. Only a bit disappointed when I would check in on her and the dialog was the same, or the lack of banter. It's fine to have them there for the players who want them. It would feel empty for me at least if I could not recruit Minthara for my evil plays.
