Originally Posted by Ixal
Most of those aren't rpgs.

They literally all are. They are just different types of RPG's. Some are ARPG's, some are JRPG's. They are still all RPG's.

Originally Posted by Ixal
And just because BG3 won many community awards doesn't mean its not a dumpster fire.

No, but it's highly successful. It has sold many copies. Ergo, it's not a dumpster fire. Not like CP2077, No Man's Sky and FO76 which were literally so bad on release that no-one bought the game. These games necessitated a lot of extra work to get them into a state where they COULD sell and make a profit. BG3 even on release sold very well, it won GOTY even before many of the patches.

BG3 has problems, it's not an amazing game. But it's far from a dumpster fire since not only has it sold well, people overall rate it favourably hence it being able to win so many awards and how many posts on the forums are about how great the game is and how much people love it.