Let's be honest: people want to leave scared facial expressions not because it deprives them of something in their roleplay, but because it deprives them of using AA's kisses as an argument for him being a rapist and abuser who enjoys Tav's fear.

I've never understood why spawn fans pretend to be AA fans, even though objectively they're not.

People here have already explained in great detail why the emotion of fear is meaningless to Tav, fear of AA in the AA route before patch 6 never happened. By all developer notes it was a consensual affair, otherwise Tav was breaking up with AA. Tav asking for freedom has the least amount of dialog in the game.

People here have written numerous times that if Tav is afraid of AA, he has the option to break up with him. Kissing with emotions of fear and resentment is disposable. You got kissed like that once - didn't like it - why go up and ask for it again? How do you explain it to yourself? I really don't get it.

I don't understand at all why spawn fans ask for something for themselves in the AA route, why don't you ask for more spawn kisses?