...when a wide character roster has characters that are so drastically underused by the community and the statistics colossally show it then obviously there is something horribly wrong with the character.
Ever heard about Loghain from Dragon Age: Origins? The dude who's recruitment was locked behind not bashing his head in?
The main reason why Minthara is so unpopular is because the most obvious story path involves burying her midst the first main quest. Not because something is horribly wrong with her..
