[
Again, what a fundamental misunderstanding of 'roleplay' concept. Role playing happens in the moment and what you describe is not role playing, but asking for some fan fiction of yours to become a universal truth set in stone for every player. I'd like an ending that is written by a professional writer who understands the material they are working with. It is not a book, not a written story and not a script, it requires interactivity, reactivity, sometimes ambiguity, painting with big strokes. No good... ta-ta! No fan fiction for me, please..
Maybe because I am an older BG player, but frankly I don't care about the distinction between fanfiction or proffesional writing, because I have played and enjoyed a lot of BG mods made by fans. Example: BG1 project, which I have enjoyed more than some of Bioware's professional writing, like Minsc, who continues to be the same old joke of a character over decades. Also, when you play a premade character, you are already playing with someone elses creation.
And so I don't care for making up a story to fill in where the writers should have done their job. This is how the dark urge run was for me and it was not fun. Larian planned from the beginning for Wyll and Karlach to be origin characters, so they knew they could be played on an evil run, so they could have come up with something. Like they had for EA Wyll.
