I thought there is already an option for Wyll to decide if he wants to save his father or break the contract. If you let him decide it, he will save his father and sign the new eternal contract. I will never let him sell his soul to any devil again. Wyll is basically the only person who keeps facing tough choices that require major sacrifices. He is too good a person to make choices that put himself first, and for that I am unapologetically interfering for sure. I have to, or this good man never gets a break in his life. To me, Wyll making his decision equals to Wyll sacrificing himself for others again, so I am not sure if this redundant option is really that necessary.
I had the scene not long ago and he looks to us expectantly to decide. While I could live with something along 'What do you think? I could use someadvice here.' from Wyll and then, if his approval is high enough, he follows our advice, I could most certainly live with that. But I feel, like we just decide that for him.
And I agree that making tough choices for the better of others and in doing so making his own life worse is kind of Wylls thing. I don't say, he never made his own decisions, in fact, I'd say, he is one of the most mature ones in decision making among the companions.
