Well, I accept that there is a certain amount of subjectivity to it. By my standards of what qualifies as a "good" playthrough, BG3 falls way short. But when it comes to the DU, it is as far as I am concerned objectively impossible for such a thing as a "good" DU playthrough. By definition, being the DU equals being evil.
You don't believe in second chances?
I think I do understand what you mean though in terms of there being no "good" equivalent to the Durge character. Every origin character in the game has some skeletons in the closet.