This is a very subjective matter, I am surprised to see it landed nr. 1 despite agreeing as a whole how amazing BG 3 has become and holds a palc ein my heart, makes me wonder though was Disco Elysium bug free when it held the place?
Very undeserved, but that is nothing new. Once the hype starts rolling no magazine dares to correct it as the "fans" will immediately attack them. See Eurogamer.