I don't think I would care much, provided the gigantic weapons never clipped into the avatar (or whatever we're wearing), but they do clip quite often - kinda all over the place.
Even when they don't clip, they simply look bad during dialogues.
As i said, they can be genuinely distracting.
You see -say- Shadowheart talking to you and on your eyes go on her back, where there's this mace/morning star/whatever that is CLEARLY oversized for her hand, with a handle as thick as a lapdancing pole.
It's ridiculous and what's worse is that it has no real reason to be this way. There would be literally no downside or technical challenge in simply doing this right.
This. Anytime there's a cutscene with with Shadowheart before she gets her hands on the moon spear or something else with a slightly more sensible scale, ALL I can see is that damn metal-crowned log hovering behind her back. It looks so utterly stupid. The morningstar is clearly the worst example, but most weapons are oversized to some degree - but not equally. Slapping on a mod that reduced weapons by say 20% across the board would leave some weapons too small instead. Anything dealing with the issue would require a fairly thorough look at the scale of each weapon model individually. It is pretty obvious that someone somewhere in the design team wasn't wearing their glasses when this was finalised.
I don't really need full transmog I don't think, since I like an aesthetic progression, I prefer some form of progressive transmog and the same with dyes, but then if the equipment is standard/non enchanted stuff I feel like that should have more customization options since we're sacrificing some power in exchange for style or more control over the visual.
I would welcome proper transmog, as long it was somewhat restricted - only being able to apply the appearance of other weapons of the same type, and only to another weapon you have acquired during that particular playthrough. Nothing like the giant transmog library of WoW where anything you ever found on any character can be used across the whole account. Works in an MMO, but BG3 is not that. I also feel there needs to be a visual progression, and lvl 1 freshies prancing around the Nautiloid with starting gear looking like end game legendaries would look more stupid than the gargantuan morning star...
