Originally Posted by Trantion
Originally Posted by Anska
The player is of course the only one who has real agency in the game and the game and it's characters react to the player's actions, so you can look up guides to plan out your companions' reactions. Taken to the extreme, you can save-scum, reload or use mods to alter the world to your liking.

Sure, if you put it like that yes, the decision-making of all video game characters is all smoke and mirrors. But I suspect people who'd like to see Wyll make his own decisions aren't planning to take a walkthrough and save-scum to make sure he makes the right decision; or if they do they still think the story would be better if he said it

That was written in response to Ragnarok's comment directly above mine that all the companions' choices are just reflections of the player's decisions, with which I disagreed. I just didn't quote the comment because it was directly above mine and I hate bloating the page by using too many or too long quotes. =)