Thanks Xenonian, but I don't think that's the case.
I did a non Durge run through prior to this one. Same approach I knocked Minthara out at the end of raid and she turned up in the cut scene in the throne room at Moonrise, and was recruitable after getting her out with a potion of invisibility. After entering Act 2. I took ages before I went to Moonrise on that run through so that I could maximise exploration XP
So you can recruit her after the raid - but apparently not this run through (so far) - must have done something different this time around
I have cleared the prison guards (got the prisoners out) will push through Shar Temple and then if all goes well I will clear as much of Moonrise as possible (no Harpers) then take a long rest and see what happens
Thanks again
