Agree with every part of your post <img src="/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/delight.gif" alt="" />
Since I am a devoter RPG player with an alignement of Chaotic Neutral (I am like Chaotic Evil for the last 3 months but hey, it's Chatic Neutral ), I would say "Kill the Child". Hell, I guess even Lawful Good would've killed the baby... but here comes the question:
What's better, to kill a person or let a million be killed? It's the most difficult question for people with lawful good alignement. Ah, it's good to be bad( ® )