BG 3 did have a young, conventionally attractive, handsome male with a sword. It's literally in his name.
But somehow he apparently didn't meet the standards, I wonder what that could have been?

Wyll suffers terribly from his character being completely changed throughout early access, so the darker and grittier edges he had are absent as of the game's official release.
Not everyone has to be dark and gritty. I love that we have at least two companions, that are different, Wyll and Karlach , well, and Gale to an extent. The dark and gritty trope gets so tiring.
Every companion is so over the top and then Wyll comes along and owns himself like a responsible person without throwing temper tantrums at every corner and it was refreshing.