Originally Posted by papercut_ninja
As an example of the opposite for comparison, Astarion and Shadowheart are high-elves / half high-elf. But being a high elf has literally no relevance or impact on them as characters. They are only high elf because they are supposed to be pretty and elf is pretty. You can swap either of them to halfling and you wouldn't have to change a single line in their entire story. This is the pretty human with pointy ears stereotype, where the pointy ears are just there as decoration and it is entirely irrelevant that they are elves in every other regard.

To be fair, the same is true for all of BG3's cast besides Lae'zel. (Karlach's being a Tiefling is only relevant in that it gives a reason why she could survive in Avernus and the burning heat of her Infernal Engine heart - Beyond that, she could be anything).

Heck, even the Emperor being an Illithid feels kind of phoned in, even if it makes it into story it doesn't have any real relevance to the character (Especially given his stance of not being interested in becoming human again, so it's not as if his transformation has given him something to overcome...). Like, they could have literally have kept him as your Guardian throughout the entire game and nothing would really change for his characterization (If anything it might have improved things because then the choice between Emperor and Orpheus would be less ridiculously one sided, because instead of being a decision between Mr Evily McEvilface and Mary Sue, one of the characters is just a plain old adventurer who helped you out instead of an evil mastermind manipulating you for their own purposes)

It's one of the disappointing aspects of BG3's writing.

Though, DOS2 was much better in that regard. Fane being an Eternal, The Red Prince being a Lizard, Beast being a Dwarf and Sebille being an Elf were much more integral to their characters and stories (Of course, Lohse and Ifan both being human was, as is typical, completely irrelevant)

So it's not as if Larian cannot write race relevancy into characters. They just opted not to for BG3 outside of Lae'zel.