Are Tuco and Taril game designers or something? They're very intense in their nitty-gritty nitpicking of Larian games. Maybe they want another Skyrim type experience? I mean their lists of nitpicks in their multiple posts are sooooo long. I personally love Larian's way of doing things since DOS1 all the way up to BG3.
I think it is perfectly fine for anyone to have strong preferences one way or another.
His criticism is fairly fair, outside claiming that Larian way of doing things no benefits.