Re: Honestly, I just want a companion like Minthara
papercut_ninja
19 minutes ago
I don't share your opinion on Minthara being that deep or interesting, even in the fully patched state (and to be honest, they really did not give her much love and care at all in the patches). But it is fine to have differing opinions - I can see the potential for an interesting and fully fleshed out character, but I think they dropped the ball with her by just abandoning her in some half-finished state and they got away with it because fans got so thirsty for the dominant drow concept that they filled in all the blanks with fantasies.
I see what you mean in that a properly written and polished character with conflicting morals and agenda to that of a player would be interesting, I just think Minthara is a very poor example because she wasn't executed well at all. It hardly matters at all what you do, as long as you side with her or knock her out in act 1 she will come along with you and have no actual relevance in act 3 beyond her commentary. For all her talk, she has no boundaries that she won't tolerate that you cross and whether she is there or not has no impact on the outcome of any choices you make. Minthara and Halsin are very superfluous characters that are just...there I guess.
Feel free to disagree, but to me everything about her is superficial, a lot fancy words and pretty visuals, but no actual bite to her story or character.