I have the lost key and want to give it to the imp and get the experience pts. But... I'm also greedy and want the stuff in his chest. Is there any way to do both? I tried pickpocket after returning his key but he didn't have anything to take. Anyone know if it's possible?
I accidentally opened the chest so I could not give him back the key. But if you want to do both it might be possible if you give him the key and later after sammy has visited the village go and look for his dead body. I do not know if it will work but it might. There is a guy with two locked chests, to get them you will need to wait till everyone is dead soo maybe....
