Larian Studios
Posted By: Shogun64 Useless thing and crafting - 04/03/22 11:36 AM
There are a lot of useless things to pick up in the game. Plants, tools, objects like bottle, retort, etc.
Rather than being useless why not develop crafting?
Characters could learn from books, with scrolls, or by talking to craftsmen, consulting private or public libraries or hidden ones. Once the knowledge and materials are acquired, the characters could make, repair or improve all sorts of things. Weapons, potions, traps, ...
Maybe even provide crafting services to NPCs and earn some gold (or secrets)
We can imagine setting up production lines (Coal + iron + forge + tool + know-how = blacksmith work)
Also some actions could be refined. To go down the hole in the chapel, you need a rope. To climb a cliff, you need a rope and a grappling hook.
I'm sure Astarion would have a lot of fun making his own poisons since he's walking around in the sun and can find a lot of plants grin
Posted By: RagnarokCzD Re: Useless thing and crafting - 04/03/22 12:44 PM
I believe crafting system has allready ben confrimmed as "planned" thing ...
But nothing closer was even told about it.
Posted By: mrfuji3 Re: Useless thing and crafting - 04/03/22 03:59 PM
-1 to a detailed crafting system that fills our inventories with dozens to hundreds of crafting materials.

Crafting limited cool things as a result of certain quests - like the Sussur Bark Questline - is the best way to go imo.
All other crafting should at most require a specific crafting kit - scroll, poison, trap, etc - a gold cost, and an appropriate skill check (also ability to cast that spell if you're making a scroll).
Posted By: Tuco Re: Useless thing and crafting - 04/03/22 04:13 PM
Originally Posted by mrfuji3
-1 to a detailed crafting system that fills our inventories with dozens to hundreds of crafting materials.

Crafting limited cool things as a result of certain quests - like the Sussur Bark Questline - is the best way to go imo.
All other crafting should at most require a specific crafting kit - scroll, poison, trap, etc - a gold cost, and an appropriate skill check (also ability to cast that spell if you're making a scroll).
Same here. I'm all for "crafting through questing" and I loathe the other ways of doing it (especially in a game that isn't procedural/systemic in nature, like a survival/builder).

Especially because the usual outcomes are that either the crafting system is completely superfluous and redundant, or conversely so are the rare items found in the game while exploring/questing/defeating strong opponents.
Posted By: Wormerine Re: Useless thing and crafting - 04/03/22 04:36 PM
Even though I stated my stance on the subject before here is another -1 as a result of playing Elden Ring. Quoting Yahtzee from Zero Punctuation:
Quote
Usually when you find stuff in Soulsy games it’s a time for celebration. Ooh, new weapons. Ooh, upgrade stones. Ooh, a small porcelain cat with a mummified finger in its mouth. Don’t know what the fuck this is but maybe I’ll yeet it at a boss and see what happens.

Not so much of that in Elden Ring when half the time it’s just more f-ing crafting materials to add to the six tons of garbage we’re hauling around in our horse’s invisible U-Haul trailer.

That mirrors more or less my personal experience, when I stopped paying attention to what I pick up very quickly because it's worth hording for crafting sake, and crafting ingredients are very not exciting to find.
Posted By: jfutral Re: Useless thing and crafting - 04/03/22 05:51 PM
Way back in the day (and I'm old enough to say that) crafting in DnD was possible, but you had to have achieved "name" level (usually around 12) and you had to take time, measured in weeks, to craft something.

I love crafting, but it is almost unnecessary with the Monty Hall of findable stuff.

Also, -1 to carrying shit around.

Joe
Posted By: andreasrylander Re: Useless thing and crafting - 04/03/22 06:33 PM
Originally Posted by jfutral
I love crafting [...]

Joe

You know who else does?

....H.P Lovecraft.

Sorry. I will stop >_<
Posted By: RagnarokCzD Re: Useless thing and crafting - 04/03/22 06:38 PM
Originally Posted by mrfuji3
-1 to a detailed crafting system that fills our inventories with dozens to hundreds of crafting materials.
I never seen any crafting system that would fill your inventory ...
Have seen a lot of people filling their inventories, for crafting system tho. O_o

But i somehow fail to see how is that systems fault. :-/
Posted By: Sozz Re: Useless thing and crafting - 04/03/22 09:14 PM
If they added an herbalist's pouch that 'bag of holding'-ing all the herbs you pick up, I probably wouldn't have carpal tunnel right now...except for the trading interface of course.
Posted By: Zellin Re: Useless thing and crafting - 04/03/22 10:58 PM
Originally Posted by RagnarokCzD
Originally Posted by mrfuji3
-1 to a detailed crafting system that fills our inventories with dozens to hundreds of crafting materials.
I never seen any crafting system that would fill your inventory ...
Have seen a lot of people filling their inventories, for crafting system tho. O_o

But i somehow fail to see how is that systems fault. :-/
I'll try to explain:
1. When a player sees a system implemented in a game the player will most likely try to use it, because said player has no way to determine if it's a major system or a minor one. In other words, if the system is vital for beating the last boss or not.
2. Also unless a game developer will unlock for players all the recipes for every single component at the very start of the game, the player has no way to tell really valuable components that will bring the victory from something they may ignore. And I'm yet to see a game developer that would just unlock all the recipes at the start, after all it would spoil the surprise for some cool stuff.
3. As a result every player that aims to play effectively feels obligated to use the crafting system. And every player that feels obligated to use the crafting system feels obligated to pick up everything just in case that it would be the component for The Master Sword ("The Legend of Zelda" reference here).
4. But none of this means that the player does feel good about it. The system practically introduces grinding mechanics to the game even if you don't need a lot of ingredients for crafting a certain piece of gear.

And yep, my vote stays where it was from the start of the EA: the crafting should be more quest-like than "go pick up some garbage to turn it into gold". There are other means to deal with cluttering with trash-items than making them useful for crafting.
Posted By: Wormerine Re: Useless thing and crafting - 04/03/22 10:59 PM
Originally Posted by Sozz
If they added an herbalist's pouch that 'bag of holding'-ing all the herbs you pick up, I probably wouldn't have carpal tunnel right now...except for the trading interface of course.
+1 that's my prefered way of doing that. Just have those items in seperate, unlimited space, unaffecting you actual inventory.
Posted By: smberg Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 12:24 AM
I actually would like to see some crafting implemented into BG3. Per the DnD 5e PHB (p. 154), “Your race, class, background, or feats give you proficiency with certain tools.” I think that it would really add to character customization and background for roleplaying if they implemented proficiency in Artisan Tools, Disguise Kit, Herbalism Kit, Poisoner’s Kit, etc. Proficiency with the Herbalism Kit, for example, would allow you to craft antitoxins and potions of healing (PHB p 154). Proficiency with the Poisoner’s Kit would allow you to craft poisons (PHB p 154). There could be some creative uses for proficiency in Disguise Kit, for example allowing you to approach a Merchant in disguise when trying to steal from them so as to not ruin your reputation if you get caught. Proficiency in Cook’s utensils allows you to craft a healing stew. Proficiency in Smith’s tools could be required to mend the broken spear or create the Sussar bark Masterwork weapons.

What I am looking for here is some added flavor that goes along with the DnD 5e guidelines. If you have the Herbalism Kit proficiency either by being a Druid or by choice at character creation, you can enjoy picking up all of those plants scattered around the world and use them in some useful but not game altering way. If you’re not into that, don’t pick that skill at character creation and ignore the plants. Likewise with Smith’s tools, if you have a dwarf or gnome in your party or if you choose that skill at character creation (say a soldier who learned that skill in the army), then you get to repair or upgrade a few cool weapons. Nothing game breaking - I don’t think that I’ve ever even used those weapons - I just carry them around in my inventory.

I do agree that I do not want it to become a huge part of the game. Just some added flavor. Larian went way overboard on these crafting things in DOS2. I don’t want that. But I would like the added character flavor that could be added if implemented in the spirit of the DnD 5e guidelines.
Posted By: mrfuji3 Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 12:33 AM
^ You can do all of the above without having dozens to hundreds of crafting ingredients strewn across the world and in merchants' inventories that inevitably go into and clutter up my inventory. Literally everything you mentioned can simply require a recipe + tool kit + perhaps equivalent gold cost + perhaps appropriate spell; recipes could be the interesting crafting finds you obtain through exploration/merchants.

+1 billion to @Zellin's explanation; well said.

But if Larian does decide to go with an overly-detailed crafting system, please please at least implement @Sozz's suggestion of a Herbalist+etc crafting pouches that everything automatically goes into. And no, backpacks that I can manually put ingredients into aren't the same, even considering the fact that further ingredients are then placed in those already-existing stacks.
Posted By: mr_planescapist Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 01:12 AM
Crafting per D&D rules would be great.

Than again Larian isn't interested in D&D rules. Its salad dressing.

At best we will get DOS2 like crafting. I mean BG3 always starts out with DOS2 systems/code for most elements right?

God what a mess this inventory system and item overloaded game. Hey, just like DOS2.
Posted By: Icelyn Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 03:59 AM
Originally Posted by andreasrylander
Originally Posted by jfutral
I love crafting [...]

Joe

You know who else does?

....H.P Lovecraft.

Sorry. I will stop >_<
😜
Posted By: GM4Him Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 05:13 AM
Every time I play, the useless junk is more annoying. I want to just hit Take All, but then I fill my inventory full of bones, plants, spoons, knives, ink wells, feather pens...

What REALLY could all these be used to craft that would be beneficial?

Recipe for crafting Plate +1
40 spoons
10 metal plates
20 forks
Mushrooms from the Underdark
Chasm Creeper
And some Rum

Is that really gonna be a thing?

Let's just cut out the junk. I don't mind it being in the game, but don't make useless junk loot you can pick up along with gold and other useful items so I can just Take All.

And PLEASE don't make crafting based on all these random items you find.
Posted By: CMK Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 08:38 AM
I wouldn't mind SOME crafting in the game, but again I am gonna echo what's been said here I don't want it to come down to collecting useless junk and hanging on to it JIC. This isn't an MMO where your bag space is determine by what pack(s) you have equipped. Where an MMO limits you on what you can carry by "bag space) slots, this game instead goes by a weight system and I already have a hard time with it just having to carry the camp supplies, potions/poisons, and extra weapons and armor that I either need
(like making sure I have a hammer or mace for the Mithril for the adamantine forge)
or are of some value and I intend to sell (yes I know I can send shit back to camp, I do that too but at times I don't want to have to play the go to camp come back game when selling shit).

IF there is going to be a crafting system of any type I'd like it to be limited to things of value (like the silver ingots I found, I would love it if there was a forge I could go to to turn it to weapon), or things we already collect (like herbs that are already collected for camp supplies maybe could be reused to make potions and poisons) and have both of these things require either kit (that doesn't weigh much) or stations already in the game
(like the work benches in the tower in the underdark)
, but even then I am not super keen on it. I don't want the grind of getting X amount of item A and X amount of item B to create Item C. First off I get enough of that in MMOs (which I hardly play anymore) second there are not spawn points where resources respawn for us to go back and get MORE of an ingredient.

I also think a crafting system would detract from the flow of the game.
Posted By: RagnarokCzD Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 10:01 AM
Originally Posted by Zellin
I'll try to explain...
Im aware. smile

I just (as usualy) see that as players decision ... not the system. smile
I mean there is no way the game can force you to do anything, they can urge you at best ... everything else is on your head. :P
Posted By: AlrikFassbauer Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 10:12 AM
Originally Posted by Shogun64
There are a lot of useless things to pick up in the game. Plants, tools, objects like bottle, retort, etc.
Rather than being useless why not develop crafting?

DDO has something like that.
Posted By: Zellin Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 10:38 AM
Originally Posted by RagnarokCzD
Originally Posted by Zellin
I'll try to explain...
Im aware. smile

I just (as usualy) see that as players decision ... not the system. smile
I mean there is no way the game can force you to do anything, they can urge you at best ... everything else is on your head. :P
Than you do not really get the 1st paragraph of my explanation. The game forces the player, because the player is supposed to play the game and the game has no way to tell the player in advance something like "this system is here just for flavor, it's not really the part of the game, ignore it if you wish".
Posted By: RagnarokCzD Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 11:09 AM
Originally Posted by Zellin
the game has no way to tell the player in advance something like "this system is here just for flavor, it's not really the part of the game, ignore it if you wish".
Except exactly this one. laugh
Wich sounds exactly as something that could easily be part of tutorial tips. :P

But even if, the game certainly do have means to tell the player exact oposite ...
I didnt play Zelda, so i dont know what you were referencing ... but personaly i would expect if the game will require me to kill last boss with a weapon that my character will personaly forge, to warn me about it before i go to that boss ... and there is many ways to do that.
Posted By: Maximuuus Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 11:29 AM
It should just be a thing in items tooltip and every readability issues would be solved (misc, decoration, crafting,...)
But then there's still the items management and I'd hate to gather tons of crafting ressources for nearly common arrows, potions and so on.

I would like a crafting system for rare items. With not even "rare" consummables.
Let's say you can find a receipe and the first component to craft a Wyvern poison (item that is way too OP but anyway) in the Hag's Lair. It could be cool.

But I'd hate a crafting system like in DoS with so many components for so many "common" items. There are already way more healing potions and magical OP arrows than necessary.
If rare component are used to create rare items, it's seems good to me. If there are plenty of common component to create plenty of common items, it's boring and not rewarding.
And it's even worse if some common component are necessary to craft rare items... Because it would mean that we'll have to gather everything, just is case...
Posted By: Wormerine Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 11:57 AM
Originally Posted by RagnarokCzD
I just (as usualy) see that as players decision ... not the system. smile
I mean there is no way the game can force you to do anything, they can urge you at best ... everything else is on your head. :P
Again. Treating games like it's some kind of choose-your-own buffet does disservice to the medium. Everything that is in the game is relevant. Having too much stuff is just as damaging and having too little. Editing in gaming exists and is needed just as much as in other mediums. Any addition to the game has positive or negative impact on the experience.

Assuming crafting will be the thing, it's speculative implementation impacts both exploration and inventory management - whenever you decide to engage with the system or not. And possible encounter balance later down the line. How one acquires new stuff in the game is an important design that will define the experience.
Posted By: RagnarokCzD Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 01:19 PM
Originally Posted by Wormerine
Treating games like it's some kind of choose-your-own buffet does disservice to the medium. Everything that is in the game is relevant.
We apparently play the games in very different way ...

For example i just now play Witcher III.
And i never felt any urge to craft every single sword, or armor that is there ... i just created Armor and Weapons from the School of Cat ... and everything else was there for me just for immersion, since it showed that Blacksmiths can do even other things. laugh
Sure, you can create every single armor and during leveling it might even come handy, since there are level requirements for stronger type of the same Witcher Gear ... so you can for a while be actualy stronger in some other gear ...
But still it just is there, and its not relevant for me at all. laugh

Originally Posted by Maximuuus
It should just be a thing in items tooltip and every readability issues would be solved (misc, decoration, crafting,...)
I like this.

Originally Posted by Maximuuus
And it's even worse if some common component are necessary to craft rare items... Because it would mean that we'll have to gather everything, just is case...
Or you can simply turn back and gather them after? O_o
I mean they are "common" after all, arent they? :P

I think we all should know by now, that if there is any certainity in this game, it is that the game WILL ALLWAYS wait for you. laugh
Posted By: Maximuuus Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 01:33 PM
Having to walk back onto every corner of an empty map to find the good plant I need to create my speed potion sounds very fun.
Posted By: CMK Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 01:47 PM
Another problem with a crafting system is that Crafted items tend to fall under three categories:

1) Consumables that help the player in battle (IE healing potions, potions of resistance etc)

2) Gear that is sub par and not worth crafting because doing a simple task/ quest replaces them

3) Gear that is so OP that it encourages you to make said item and skip side quests and leads to the cycle of get better gear to defeat bigger bosses to get better gear mentality


I got no problem with the first type in general other than the fact that in this game what you can carry is based on weight based on your strength score thus making hauling about lots of materials a pain

The second is problem that can be solved in MOST MMOs by making the gear just good enough to allow you to do the quest/ dungeon/ raid to get the item you really want, but this game does not in anyway function like an MMO (at least not any current MMOs) since there are no instanced dungeons with a "Gear Score" it would make it difficult to know if gathering the materials to craft a piece of gear is worth it or not especially in D&D setting where sometimes you stumble across magical gear just by looking in the correct crate.

The third... as I stated before it encourages you to skip side quests... something that can be done easily in an MMO as you can always go back to them and do them, but in this type of game which encourages exploration and doing the side quests (which provide not only gear, but the XP you need) its not a good idea/ takes away from the game to skip side quests. Which brings me to the point that I am sure Larian didn't go through all the trouble of writing all this storyline with multiple permutations based on our actions as players just to have us get bogged down in a tiered crafting system. They'd probably rather we enjoy playing out the story.

Honestly all in all (and I am sorry if this sounds hostile) if you want an entire crafting system just play an MMO...
Posted By: jfutral Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 01:57 PM
The crafting system and random detritus was the worst part of Witcher crafting. I can't remember from NWN.

I'm playing Solasta and I'm digging the system there. It tracks the recipes you have learned, which ones you can make with the ingredients you have, and which ingredients you are missing. I don't particularly care for managing my inventory, but at least I CAN just go around merrily picking up plants and stuff. Although I'm never quite sure what might be a needed ingredient down the road and which is sellable loot. I see the "Ingredient" tag on the item, but not sure if I can always trust it.

What I liked about crafting in D:OS, I was being able to make weapons I couldn't buy or find. They weren't Specialist flashy, but the damage was amaze-balls. Then they ditched it in D:OS II. smirk

Joe
Posted By: jfutral Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 01:58 PM
Originally Posted by GM4Him
Every time I play, the useless junk is more annoying. I want to just hit Take All, but then I fill my inventory full of bones, plants, spoons, knives, ink wells, feather pens...

What REALLY could all these be used to craft that would be beneficial?

Recipe for crafting Plate +1
40 spoons
10 metal plates
20 forks
Mushrooms from the Underdark
Chasm Creeper
And some Rum

THAT would be awesome.

Joe
Posted By: GM4Him Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 02:01 PM
All these things you've said... That's why I really don't craft in video games. I don't care for it at all.

That said, Solasta did crafting okay but still not great. I did craft some in that game because I had to in order to get some better gear. Doom Gem + Greatsword + something else = Cool Greatsword that was better than other greatswords.

Problem was, it wasn't long before I didn't need to craft anything else or buy anything else, and most items I found were boring because I already had better gear.

So then, still picking up useless junk and managing it for nothing and then items I'd find that might have been super cool were not.

Kinda like how they let you acquire Zalk's sword in the prologue. No other weapon in EA compares. So, everything else is boring at that point.
Posted By: jfutral Re: Useless thing and crafting - 05/03/22 02:04 PM
Originally Posted by GM4Him
All these things you've said... That's why I really don't craft in video games. I don't care for it at all.

That said, Solasta did crafting okay but still not great. I did craft some in that game because I had to in order to get some better gear. Doom Gem + Greatsword + something else = Cool Greatsword that was better than other greatswords.

Problem was, it wasn't long before I didn't need to craft anything else or buy anything else, and most items I found were boring because I already had better gear.

So then, still picking up useless junk and managing it for nothing and then items I'd find that might have been super cool were not.

Kinda like how they let you acquire Zalk's sword in the prologue. No other weapon in EA compares. So, everything else is boring at that point.

Balance seems to always be the holy grail.

Joe
Posted By: Wormerine Re: Useless thing and crafting - 06/03/22 12:13 AM
Originally Posted by RagnarokCzD
For example i just now play Witcher III.
And i never felt any urge to craft every single sword, or armor that is there ... i just created Armor and Weapons from the School of Cat ... and everything else was there for me just for immersion, since it showed that Blacksmiths can do even other things. laugh
Sure... crafting in WitcherIII (and in general RPG systems) were pretty poor. Considering that after 10+ hours of gameplay I outleveled any content I wanted to tackle, yeah new gear acquisition was pretty irrelevant outside looking nice. That's also good example, thanks. Erase power progression, and RPGness of Witcher3 and you immediately get a better game. Do something well, or don't do that at all.
Posted By: Niara Re: Useless thing and crafting - 06/03/22 03:02 AM
I know a game where any object that is used in crafting has, on its tooltip, "used in:" and then a short list of small print lines for the crafting recipes it's used in. This doesn't spoil anything in advance, since you only know what something is useful for when you've gotten your hands on it - not that you need a specific dragon's heart to make something before you even meet said dragon. In a game where certain items are used in many recipes, it can cut off after three entries with a "(and 27 other recipes)" line, which can be popped out further with another key stroke if you want to read the full list. Something like this could work here, to stop you worrying about what useless clutter to pick up and what not to.
Posted By: GM4Him Re: Useless thing and crafting - 06/03/22 03:58 AM
But why? Why craft swords, axes, armor, etc. that are normal at all? To make more junk that doesn't sell for much?

I agree with those who say the only worthwhile items to craft are items like Sussur weapons or Adamantine or whatever. All the crafting you can do with spoons, knives, forks, plates, cups, etc. would be boring junk items you probably won't ever actually use. You'd just sell them.

So why not cut out the useless junk in the game and just have useful items, more gold, rather than collect and sell useless junk, and so forth?

At least make all the useless stuff things I'd actually have to pick up on a table or shelf, not within lootable inventories.

Right now, if an enemy has even one useless item, like a bone, I have to either take it with good stuff, with Take All, or I take each item I want one item at a time. So, my inventory winds up filling up with garbage I just sell, one item at a time, because it's just easier to Take All.
Posted By: RutgerF Re: Useless thing and crafting - 06/03/22 04:29 AM
Well, I'd love to be able to craft a full plate - I don't see them being sold anywhere.

Also, I tend to like the crafting system in NWN2. Sure, most of the recipes were useless, just like most mundane items are useless. However, the ability to choose a different base material for some items was a really nice touch - Mithril Chain Shirt, anyone?
Posted By: RagnarokCzD Re: Useless thing and crafting - 06/03/22 06:54 AM
Originally Posted by GM4Him
But why? Why craft swords, axes, armor, etc. that are normal at all?
Why not? O_o

My Dwarf, Guild Artisan, will allways rather fight with arms and armor that he made himself, than in armor he find on (or in) some corpse ... laugh
Posted By: Gray Ghost Re: Useless thing and crafting - 06/03/22 08:29 AM
Well the answer to why not is that if you're also able to craft magical weapons, then as soon as you're able to do that, the normal weapons and any ingredients reqauired exclusively for them become useless, because why would you craft and use a normal weapon when you can craft and use a magical weapon that's just objectively better. That means the devs are investing time and money into content that's going to see very little use, as well as cluttering up the world and system with undesireable stuff that players don't want.

Also your argument about crafting that if a player doesn't like it they can just not engage with it rings false for several reasons. The first is that, as it was pointed out, unless the game explicitly says that players don't have to engage with the crafting system, players won't know that they have a choice, and they're going to waste time gathering up all the overabundant resources Larian has dropped in the game, which slows down gameplay. And honestly, do you actually think Larian will explicitly say "don't worry about crafting, it's entirely optional for you to do"? Why would they invest time and effort into a system that can be ignored without impacting the game experience? Why would we assume that they would tell us if their crafting system was totally optional? I can give you a reason they would not do that; because they worked hard on it and want players to interact with it. If they didn't want players to interact with it, they wouldn't have included it in the first place.

Also, the idea that crafting will actually not impact the game experience and it's a thing that'll be completely optional is just silly. On lower difficulties you'd probably be able to ignore it, but for anyone who wants to play on higher difficulties, I've yet to see a game like this where part of the higher difficulty doesn't involve making serious use of items and constantly having the best possible weapons and potions and items, which pretty much always involves some level of crafting. Then there's the fact that if the system exists, then the devs are going to let that impact other development aspects. It'll impact loot at the very least, because crafting supplies are going to be all over, and it's inevitable that players will pick some up even without going out of their way to get it, which will clutter up their items. Then we have no idea how it will impact power scaling. Will there be stuff that can only be crafted? Does all this mean that someone who dislikes the crafting but is finding the game too easy at the level which allows them to ignore the crafting will have to pick between two unpleasant experiences?
Posted By: RagnarokCzD Re: Useless thing and crafting - 06/03/22 09:49 AM
Originally Posted by Gray Ghost
Well the answer to why not is that if you're also able to craft magical weapons, then as soon as you're able to do that, the normal weapons and any ingredients reqauired exclusively for them become useless
Not necesarily ...
Personaly i still believe that +1 crafted items should be treated as meere upgrade of regular weapon ... meaning requiring you to use regular weapon as one of ingredients ...
Sure, you can also totally use litteraly any other weapon you just looted somewhere, but if you just happen to not have any ... regular weapon have still its uses. :P

One old expression say: Those who wants, are looking for answer to how ... those who dont want, are looking for answer for why. smile
Or something like that. laugh

Originally Posted by Gray Ghost
That means the devs are investing time and money into content that's going to see very little use, as well as cluttering up the world and system with undesireable stuff that players don't want.
Its funny how often players want to decide what investment is meaningfull and what not, purely on their own desires without any context. laugh Thanks Gods it dont work this way.

I wonder why are you talking about yourself in plural ...
It would be much more acurate if you would say "stuff that i dont want". laugh

Nah, just messing with you smile ... im aware there are certainly "more than 1" people against it ... but im also aware there is certainly "more than 1" people waiting for that feature ...
Now wich group is bigger?
That would be good question ... but i doubt any of us even can know. smile

So please, dont make yourself majority ... it dont give your arguments any value ... at best it have exactly oposite effect. laugh

Originally Posted by Gray Ghost
they're going to waste time gathering up all the overabundant resources Larian has dropped in the game, which slows down gameplay
Sad story ...
But how is that an argument? And what are you even trying to say? laugh

"It should not be implemented at all, bcs otherwise people would use it." ? O_o

Im really confused by this logic. laugh

I feel like im just back in Barrells topic, where some of you were trying to persuate me that people will waste hunderts of hours to move Barrells around, just to blow up whole Goblin camp "easily" ... instead of making it the "hard and skillfull way" and kill them with their spells and abilities ... wich is both more fun and faster ...

Or in that short topic about rolling our stats, where someone was trying to tell us that people will waste whole months, maybe even years, trying to get 18 18 18 18 18 18. laugh

Yeah, some certainly will ... and they mostly will bcs they choose to.
Same as every time before ... if you do something you dont want do ... there is something horribly wrong. :-/

Originally Posted by Gray Ghost
Why would they invest time and effort into a system that can be ignored without impacting the game experience?
This is a good question ...
I would like to point out that we will have 12 classes, of wich every have at least 2 sub-classes ... wich means certainly more than 24 options, lets say "around 30" +/- ...
And our group will be able to contain only 4 characters ...
And yes, im aware that we could technicaly play more than 4 since Multiclass is a thing ... but that only alterns the question to max level features. laugh

I would also like to point out that there is really MANY magical items in the game, and quite honestly no matter how hard you try you will never be able to use them all.

Same goes with races, same goes with backstories, same goes with alternative quest decisions, same goes with main questline (support, or fight the Absolute), same goes with spells, same goes with consumable items, throwable items, ... basicaly freaking everything in this game. laugh

So why would they invest time and effort into a system that can be ignored without impacting the game experience? smile
Oh thats right, so people have OPTIONS! laugh

Originally Posted by Gray Ghost
Also, the idea that crafting will actually not impact the game experience and it's a thing that'll be completely optional is just silly.
I for one never said (and as far as i know neither did anyone else) it will "not impact the game experience" ... the topic was it would not be cruicial.
Meaning that you will never meet an enemy who "can be harmed only when weapon is held by the hand that made it". laugh

[quote=Gray Ghost]I've yet to see a game like this where part of the higher difficulty doesn't involve making serious use of items and constantly having the best possible weapons and potions and items, which pretty much always involves some level of crafting. Then there's the fact that if the system exists, then the devs are going to let that impact other development aspects. It'll impact loot at the very least, because crafting supplies are going to be all over, and it's inevitable that players will pick some up even without going out of their way to get it, which will clutter up their items. Then we have no idea how it will impact power scaling. Will there be stuff that can only be crafted? Does all this mean that someone who dislikes the crafting but is finding the game too easy at the level which allows them to ignore the crafting will have to pick between two unpleasant experiences?
Im not quite sure what are you talking about here ...
"Best possible weapons"? Come on, every common vendor offers you some +1 gear. laugh
"Potions and items"? In my last play i gathered around 60 Healing potions ... i dont see any reason why would i craft more. laugh
Same goes with throwable items ...
Im not quite sure how resistance potions will play ... are you allowed to drink two of them? Or all of them? And if so ... what would be the reason to double your enemy damage by setting game on Hard, if you would imediatly lower it back in half by crafting resistance potions? laugh
So you can tap your own shoulder that you beated the game on Hard? laugh

About loot ... i dont think it will affect this aspect of game ... well, at all to be honest ... since we allready have herbs, empty vials, bottles, ropes, hammers, ignots and tongs all over the place. :-/

The rest is your pure fantasy with no real tie to the game ... so i shall ignore that if you dont mind.
Bcs the only acceptable answer for "what if" in my eyes is "what if not". laugh
Posted By: Shogun64 Re: Useless thing and crafting - 06/03/22 10:34 AM
Originally Posted by mrfuji3
-1 to a detailed crafting system that fills our inventories with dozens to hundreds of crafting materials.

Crafting limited cool things as a result of certain quests - like the Sussur Bark Questline - is the best way to go imo.
All other crafting should at most require a specific crafting kit - scroll, poison, trap, etc - a gold cost, and an appropriate skill check (also ability to cast that spell if you're making a scroll).

Yes and no.
With the system of sending items directly to the trunk the inventory is not really a problem. But sorting and organizing it is. In general, you have a bad overview of the inventory. This is general to games of this type for the most part. I think there is really something to develop there. I mean the organization of the inventory (not SAP please)
BUT personally sending the items to the chest directly bothers me. It's too "magical". So do the camps that come out of nowhere. Maybe the heroes have a purse with the camp in it and they take it out of their pocket when they want to camp? This is 'Jack Vance' not 'The Forgotten Realms' hehe
Posted By: Shogun64 Re: Useless thing and crafting - 06/03/22 10:42 AM
Originally Posted by Sozz
If they added an herbalist's pouch that 'bag of holding'-ing all the herbs you pick up, I probably wouldn't have carpal tunnel right now...except for the trading interface of course.
+1
Idem for for gems and parchment scrolls
same as BG2
Posted By: Shogun64 Re: Useless thing and crafting - 06/03/22 10:49 AM
+1
Posted By: Shogun64 Re: Useless thing and crafting - 06/03/22 10:51 AM
Originally Posted by mrfuji3
^ You can do all of the above without having dozens to hundreds of crafting ingredients strewn across the world and in merchants' inventories that inevitably go into and clutter up my inventory. Literally everything you mentioned can simply require a recipe + tool kit + perhaps equivalent gold cost + perhaps appropriate spell; recipes could be the interesting crafting finds you obtain through exploration/merchants.

+1 billion to @Zellin's explanation; well said.

But if Larian does decide to go with an overly-detailed crafting system, please please at least implement @Sozz's suggestion of a Herbalist+etc crafting pouches that everything automatically goes into. And no, backpacks that I can manually put ingredients into aren't the same, even considering the fact that further ingredients are then placed in those already-existing stacks.
+1
Posted By: GM4Him Re: Useless thing and crafting - 06/03/22 12:55 PM
All I know is, item management is one of the most boring and time consuming elements of the game right now.

And it's always been for me and my players one of the most boring elements in tabletop.

In tabletop, I don't have players gathering ingredients for crafting. They don't explore dungeons and while doing so I say, "You find a chasm Creeper. Would you like to take it? It's a crafting item.". If they want to craft something, I make them pay the crafting materials price.

And I do everything in my power to avoid cluttering inventories so that players aren't writing down tons and tons of useless junk. I'll even turn it right into money so we don't waste time managing it or later worrying about "selling" it. My players find merchant visits boring.

And notice, in D&D they try to even make it simple so you don't have to write down every item you might need. A Dungeoneer Kit simplifies things. If you have one, you know you are automatically carrying certain items. Thieves tools mean you have lock picks and cutting tools needed to disarm traps. You don't write down that you have 6 picks, a pair of scissors, wire cutters, etc.

But in BG3, we pick up so much stuff. SO much. Again, extremes. BG3 is full of extremes. Simplify. Tame it down. We don't need all the useless stuff to manage.
© Larian Studios forums