This is the full dialogue
with Rhalic, but the important part is here:
Right after that, I spoke with Lohse, and I have those options:
Rhalic never said a word about Lohse. It said some of my companions might have met a God too, but he certainly didn't say that Lohse was a liability or that I should get rid of her.
I don't think I missed something speaking with Rhalic, so where does this information come from? And surely, if I never hear Rhalic speaking about Lohse, I should not have the possibility to tell her that.