I got the Paid the Price conditions for making the deal with the hag.
Problem 1: During the dialogue it sounds like the characters are describing the eye changing color or something, but on inspection nothing has changed. Don't know if this is because I'm playing a Tiefling with demon eyes, but seems strange. Also the eye used in the cinematic is a generic eyeball and does not match characters.
Problem 2?: I have now killed the hag, but the condition remains - is this intentional?