I just got one question here. Where is the hint that you need to blow out that torch? This is the second quest I've had to check the forum to finish, the first was the waterguy. Will this whole game continue like this with absolutely no clue to what you have to do to finish quests?
I'm normally quite good at solving quests in games, but this game just doesn't give you anything to work on. Not that I've seen anyways. I don't like running to forums to solve quests, it makes you lazy and you stop exploring valid options because you reason it's prolly one of this impossible or buglike (water bottle) things again. I hope this will get some attention in future patches. In this case, how about some wall or parchment nearby saying something like "in darkness we thrive" or whatever. Just give a hint.
Again I might have missed the hint, in that case I hope someone can point it out so I won't miss the next.
/Illuminatis