I would like a game that can be finished in 30-40 hours and is well balanced for that period of time. I don't want a gazillion of features that most likely break a lot of stuff as it is next to impossible to test all possible combinations of these features.
I would like a game that can be modded to bring all those nice-to-have features to those who are interested in them.
I would like a game that, in the event it can't be modded, does not try to implement all those nice-to-have features and just stick to the ones that improve gameplay without actually breaking it.