Quote
Where exactly was the illogic in that?

You giving completely unrelated comment and trying to avoid my previous statement by supplying your words with an unrelated question and yet at the the same you perfectly understand what I meant.
I see you have a lot of troll experience, nice to know :p

Quote
How about a source printed 6 years ago, long before any changes in D2:ED releases?

SENSE.
LOGIC.
you make none.
I was talking ONLY about D2, it is YOU who were talking about BD and DD, which is.. kinda weird, since Ssassan question belongs to D2 only.
But it's ok, I understand, you wanted to make your point no matter what.

Quote
Everything in the game is a gameplay element.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gameplay
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plot_(narrative)
http://critical-gaming.blogspot.com/2008/07/how-to-write-critical-video-game-review.html

First, to state your opinion you're making simple things difficult, now, we can see a different picture: you're tying to simplify a difficult things.

It is fun how things turn out, isn't? :P

Quote
I thought the discussion was about whether a particular quest in D2:ED makes sense within that game world? An opinion poll on which game has the better plot is irrelevant.

Nice try to avoid my point. I guess you clearly understand what I meant but do want to avoid it :P
I tried to show you objective pov about D2 plot: if my opinion can be just my opinion and nothing more, then set of opinions you can't ignore, otherwise you gonna admit you're blind and stubborn fanboi.
But -- as you say -- you're not, righty-righty? :P

ligthwarrior
http://www.larian.com/forums/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=390872