Well, you still haven't actually said anything at all. You've told us all an idea won't work and you've provided zero justification for your argument. Mostly you're just coming across as a negative asshole.

I tend to keep an open mind about such possibilities... but perhaps that's blinded me to something you're aware of that I'm not.

So, if you've got a rationale for why the above is an improper or poor system you're more than welcome to explain why.