How am I "dancing around" the issue? He posted his idea, I commented on it.
Because the "issue" is you answering the question: "WHY won't his idea work?"...which you are intentionally not answering.
As I've already said, his idea would never work. I don't know how I can be more clear than that.
BTW do you ever plan on actually commenting on his idea or did you just come in here to critique my posts? I find it ironic that you repeatedly complain about my posts, all the while saying NOTHING relevant to this thread.