Hello again.
I had not gone thru the earth elemental portal. I did and triggered a conversation with the Trife. After that The Chapel opened up and I talked to Astarte.
But when i went back to Icara she still tells me i need more Star Stone !
I went back to ALL the rooms in HomeStead. No luck.
Teleported to Phantom Forest. Fought some leftover monsters. Saved. Went back to HomeStead.
Icara still tells me I need more Star Stones.
What would you suggest I try now?