Great write-up but a bit overly negative too. I get it, its incredibly frustrating to see something -very- close to greatness be marred and flawed, but excessive bitching is just that, and doesn't really serve anyone IMHO.
Don't get me wrong, your arguments were salient 9 out of 10 on content, but maybe 7/10 on delivery since it was a bit acerbic. Stylistically though, its right up my alley 10/10.
The only contradictory element is that you call for the delta of randomness which I 100% agree with but then complain that initiative as implemented now makes each turn completely unpredictable. Bit of an opposing statement, but I take your meaning which is the randomness should come in other more logical ways not from flawed mechanics.
Last edited by Darkwind; 27/09/17 07:27 AM.