I actually preferred PoE2's way of doing it and allowing for both systems being in place.
That being said, I almost always RP a rogue, or DW, or DPS class in any RPG. Unfortunately, many TB games don't lend themselves to a high attack speed, DPS character. If they can balance it in such a way that this is possible, then I'd almost always go for a TB game (being a F1/2 addict).
If that isn't possible, then RTwP is my go to and currently is in PoE2 due to TB not allowing any attack speed class.