No hes very much right.
The complaints are either about minor details like some rules alteration or about broad thigns with no proof.

Ive asked you , multiple times, about providing screenshots from baldurs gate 1 and 2 and comparing them to screenshtos of baldurs gate 3 and telling me where the difference in tone is.
And so far nobody has actually done that.

Whcih leads me to believe that you have no atual argument and are just mad.