Ok, so because 25 fedora hat wearing geeks that are tabletop d&d fans are complaining - now developers suddenly needs to change their direction?
Guess what, divinity combat was more fun than Boring gate 1&2. Pillars of Eternity was more fun. None of them are d&d games.
Game mechanics are game mechanics, main thing is to be balanced, challenging and fun.
Also, tip of the hat to you:
Its not suddenly changing its actually following what the marketing said before we purchased.. There was sudden changes away from D&D 5e rules imo.
Originally Posted by Rhobar121
I'll just leave it here
"Baldur's Gate 3 will similarly give players lots of tools and then let them have at it. "We'll stay true to our roots," says Vincke, "so we'll give players lots of systems, and lots of agency to use these systems and try to accomplish what you need to on your adventure. That's not going to change; that's the core of what we're doing." There are some things on the chopping block, however. It's an interpretation of D&D, specifically 5th Edition, because porting the core rules, which Larian tried to do, doesn't work. Or it works, Vincke clarifies, but it's no fun at all. One of the culprits is missing when you're trying to hit an enemy, and while the combat system has yet to be revealed, you can at least look forward to being able to smack people more consistently.
"You miss a lot in D&D—if the dice are bad, you miss," he says. "That doesn't work well in a videogame. If I do that, you're going to review it and say it's shit. Our approach has been implementing it as pure as we can, and then just seeing what works and what doesn't. Stuff that doesn't work, we start adapting until it does."
This interpretation should still be more true to the tabletop RPG than its predecessors, however, capturing the feel of D&D even if it's not borrowing every single system and rule. Some of this is because of a difference in technology. Black Isle faced a lot of limitations that Larian doesn't. The studio has invested heavily in this side of things, as well as in staff, who now number in the hundreds."