Sure ...
Unless you focus on that lost ... first of all, her "master" was attacked by Gnolls while she(?) played and singed on a road ...
- we can expect her singing was what draw Gnolls towards them
- even if not, it we were specificly told by Alfira, that they didnt "hear" that attack over her "master" song ... therefeore, if she would shut up, everyone would have ben much happier
- and finaly ... Alfira specificly tells you, when you sugest that she should rather learn to fight, instead of singing ... that "not everything is solved by weapons" (or something like that) ... i would SO MUCH like to tell her something like "yeah, except saving your master, when you were attacked ... duh" :-/
Plus as i said, i really dont like bards ...
Marigold (Dandelion in english version ... dunno about other languages) is in my opinion the most anoying person in whole Witcher universe, and i will never understand why Geralt didnt kill him long ago. :-/ I would.
