Yes. Elves should, according to a lot of people, appear as you've shown. However, again, there are also plenty of other artistic renditions that show elves looking more like humans with pointy ears.

So, can we agree that they need more options and shouldn't take away any? Please more elvish faces like the above pics but don't get rid of any current models for those people who want an elf that looks like a human with pointy ears.