Re: Minthara Not Being Recognised And Not Increasing Approval. - (Bug, PC)
Xenonian
9 hours ago
Unfortunately it is either a design flaw with how you recruited her (regarding hostility) that is acting up or Minthara otherwise being buggy with the conversations, she's typically been behaving like some form of spaghetti code.
Where old legacy conversations that are disabled by design ends up being inadvertedly activated, where fixing some of her bugs keep resurfacing, I suspect you would not have this (going hostile in camp) issue if you had recruited Minthara the intended way developers envisioned in the first place where you side with goblins, not like that matters with what else is problematic.
Scripting got revised I believe (could be wrong) that was suppose to have been a permanent fix for where Minthara refuses to follow the player after being rescued from the Moonrise tower for example but I've still seen topics since then of people experiencing this issue, mainly on console.
I don't need to see video to understand your issue and unfortunately have not encountered it myself and only suggestion I can say is to send a bug report to Larian with a clear explaining of certain conversations not being flagged properly or something along those lines, they will also likely ask you of providing a save file in that case.
https://larian.com/support/faqs/how-to-submit-a-bug-report_85P.S. Sometimes conversation dialogues that act as one-off moments can reset when the character that initiates it has been cast Disguise Self, maybe have fun toying around with that.